A frame-by-frame review of André's driver swing from October 28, filmed roughly face-on from a distance, slightly from the trail side, with no range screen in the clip. It is report #5 for the driver and uses the full reference frame (grid, center lines, diagonals, head and waist heights), with body rotation estimates and a clear list of next steps.
Bottom line: a very quiet head, but a long, slow backswing and a sideways hip drift. The head dropped only ~0.5 in by impact, which ties his best driver reading (reports #3 and #4). The downswing was a fast 0.22 s, and the turn was strong: about 85° of shoulder turn against ~40° of hip turn, an X-factor of ~45°. With no range screen and no ball tracking, there is no ball flight to report for this swing, so the diagnosis rests on movement alone.
The two things to work on are the same as in his last two driver reports: the hips sit ~5 in sideways from their address line at impact (~4 in of it already by the top), and the tempo is ~6.2:1, a backswing of 1.34 s against the Tour 0.80 s. Honest note: every number here matches reports #3 and #4 exactly, so this is most likely the same clip analyzed again, and it adds no new data point. The driver is now at 5 of 10 reports.
Head ~0.5 in lower at impact, ties his best. Hips also stay at the same height (~0.8 in lower).
Hips ~5 in sideways from the address line at impact, ~4 in of it by the top. The turn should happen between the hip lines.
1.34 s back and 0.22 s down is ~6.2:1. A backswing near 0.8–0.9 s would bring it toward the Tour 3:1.
41.82 frames per second, so each time is accurate to about ±0.024 s. The backswing starts at about 1.75 s (frame 73), the top is at 3.08 s (frame 129), and impact is at about 3.30 s (frame 138).
| Group | Backswing | Downswing | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| André (driver #5, Oct 28) | ~1.34 s | ~0.22 s | ~6.2:1 |
| André (driver #1, Oct 7) | ~0.50 s | ~0.25–0.30 s | ~2:1 |
| André (driver #2, Oct 10) | ~0.60 s | ~0.33 s | ~2:1 |
| André (driver #3 and #4, Oct 28) | ~1.34 s | ~0.22 s | ~6.2:1 |
| André (3-wood #1, Oct 24) | ~0.50 s | ~0.30 s | ~1.7:1 |
| PGA Tour (Tour Tempo, "24/8") | ~0.80 s | ~0.27 s | 3:1 |
Tour figure: John Novosel, Tour Tempo. One frame either way moves the ratio between ~5.6:1 and ~7:1.
What it means: The downswing (0.22 s) is quick, even a little faster than the Tour 0.27 s, which suits a driver. The backswing is the unusual part: 1.34 s is nearly twice the Tour figure and about 2.5 times his own earlier driver backswings (0.50–0.60 s). Part of it may be a slow start or a pause near the top, which the video alone can't split from the swing itself.
Nine key positions, filmed roughly face-on from a distance, slightly from the trail side. The target is to the right of the frame and the backswing goes to the left.
Photos are numbered in the order they happen in the swing. The frames follow the standard swing positions.
| Measure (vs address) | Top | Impact | #3 / #4 Oct 28 (top / impact) | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Head, down | ~0.4 in | ~0.5 in | — / ~0.5 in | Good ties his best |
| Head, sideways | ~1.1 in | ~2.2 in | — / — | Watch small drift |
| Hips, sideways | ~4.2 in | ~5.2 in | ~4 in / ~5 in | Fix most of it happens by the top |
| Hips, height | ~0.5 in lower | ~0.8 in lower | — / — | Good no rising |
| Hands vs address spot | ~16.7 in | ~6.5 in | — / ~6.5 in | Fix far from the start spot |
| Shoulder turn (shoulders open at impact) | ~85° | ~20° open | ~85° / — | Strong turn, ±10–15° |
| Hip turn (hips open at impact) | ~40° | ~35° open | ~40° (#3), ~45° (#4) / — | Hips lead the shoulders at impact |
| X-factor (shoulder minus hip turn) | ~45° | — | ~45° (#3), ~40° (#4) / — | Good coil, ±10–15° |
| Tempo (back / down) | 1.34 s | 0.22 s | ~6.2:1 / — | Watch ~6.2:1, slow back |
Depth note: the camera is slightly on the trail side, so some of the "sideways" hip and head movement may be depth, and one angle can't split the two. That the hips are already ~4 in out at the top, with only ~1 in more through impact, makes this worth checking. A level, square-on clip from closer in would settle it.
| Report | Head, down at impact | Hips, sideways by impact | Tempo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Driver #1 · Oct 7 (down-the-line) | ~5 in | — | ~2:1 |
| Driver #2 · Oct 10 (face-on) | — | ~3 in | ~2:1 |
| Driver #3 and #4 · Oct 28 (face-on) | ~0.5 in | ~5 in | ~6.2:1 |
| Driver #5 · Oct 28 (this swing) | ~0.5 in | ~5.2 in | ~6.2:1 |
| 3-Wood #1 · Oct 24 | — | — | ~1.7:1 |
The link: the head dip is the big change. It went from ~5 in in the first driver report to ~0.5 in in the last three, and the longer, slower backswing came with it. The hip drift and the backswing tempo are the two things still moving the wrong way. His other clubs run 1.7–2:1, so the 6.2:1 driver tempo stands out in the logbook. With no ball data for this swing, whether the quieter head helps ball flight is still open.
Confidence: high on tempo (measured frame by frame); moderate on head and hip distances (grid scaled from body size, ±1 inch); low on the sideways-versus-depth split and on turn angles (visual estimates, about ±10–15°); no ball-flight data for this swing.
Film face-on again with the phone at belt height. Turn so the belt buckle stays between the two dashed hip lines at the top. Hit 10 balls.
Feel: "turn in a barrel, don't slide." The ~4 in already gone by the top should shrink.
Count "one-two-three" on the way back and hit on "four", keeping the same fast downswing.
Aims for a backswing near 0.8–0.9 s, which brings the ratio toward 3:1 without slowing the 0.22 s downswing.
Whatever he did to keep the cap on its line (~0.5 in lower at impact): keep it.
It is the best head reading for this club, matched in three reports now.
Hips are about 35° open at impact against shoulders at about 20°. Keep that order.
It is the right sequence for a driver and supports the fast 0.22 s downswing.
Next capture: to sharpen the reference frame: (1) a face-on clip at belt height, square to the target line, (2) the range screen after each shot, (3) the club sole to the camera for the club check, (4) 3–5 balls for an average, and (5) André's height, to lock the grid scale.